This Company Turns American Milk Into Canadian Cheese. Tariffs Are Curdling Those Plans.

· Reason

When President Donald Trump escalated his trade war with Canada earlier this year by slapping huge new tariffs on dairy products, the White House framed it as an attempt to strike back against Canadian protectionism.

Visit betsport.cv for more information.

Those trade barriers, the White House said, would "make America wealthier and stronger, offsetting the burden and disadvantage" of the tariffs Canada was already charging against American dairy that crossed the border. 

That approach assumes that Canadian dairy and American dairy are two completely separate products and that giving one an advantage means disadvantaging the other.

From Tom Gellert's vantage point, that doesn't make much sense. 

"Half of the cheese that we import from Canada to the U.S. is made with U.S. milk," says Gellert, the co-CEO of Gellert Global Group, a New Jersey–based food importer and distributor. That milk comes from farms in New York, Wisconsin, the Dakotas, and elsewhere, and it makes its way to processing plants in Ontario to be turned into cheese and other products. 

With American tariffs now at 50 percent—and with some dairy products banned outright by presidential decree—Gellert says that cross-border business model has become "unsustainable." His business has already taken an estimated $40 million hit.

But what about the claims that Canada is taking advantage of American dairy farmers by charging astronomically high tariffs? As Trump has put it: "So we want to sell milk into Canada, and they throw a 270 percent price increase on the milk."

That's wildly misleading, says Gellert. Those tariffs don't kick in until after American imports hit a certain quota, which was set by the terms of the United States–Canada-Mexico Agreement (USMCA), the very trade deal that Trump negotiated during his first term. "I don't think it's an intellectually honest debate on the Canadian trade restrictions," says Gellert.

Indeed, Canada is the second-largest export market for American dairy products, behind only Mexico. Total American dairy exports to Canada climbed by 67 percent between 2021 and 2024, thanks in large part to the USMCA. Trump's trade war has put that growth in jeopardy and crushed the cross-border supply chains that businesses such as Gellert Global Group—and its 700 employees—depend on.

"We can't continue to pay 50 percent tariffs because we just can't afford to be giving money to the Treasury Department versus investing in the business," Gellert says.

Gellert has tried lobbying Congress and the Trump administration to ease the tariffs. Now the company is turning to the courts. Gellert Global Group is now the lead plaintiff in a lawsuit filed in the U.S. Court of International Trade that challenges the tariffs on Canadian imports. The company is working with the Liberty Justice Center, the same nonprofit law firm that successfully overturned Trump's "emergency" tariffs in a case decided by the Supreme Court earlier this year. 

The legal arguments for these trade barriers are as shaky as the economic arguments the administration has offered to justify them. 

To impose those tariffs, Trump reached for Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930, which has not been used since the Great Depression. Some legal scholars, such as Philip Zelikow, a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution, argue that the law is defunct because it has been superseded by other legislation. Others argue that Trump's use of Section 338 is an unlawful expansion of executive power that violates the "major questions" doctrine—the same issue that helped sink Trump's earlier tariffs at the Supreme Court. 

In the lawsuit, the Liberty Justice Center and Gellert Global Group outline five reasons why the tariffs should be struck down. Even if the law hasn't been superseded by other provisions, the Trump administration has failed to properly follow it, their suit argues. 

For businesses like Gellerts, the completely unnecessary trade war between the U.S. and Canada has been a major disruption that offers nothing in return. Making Canadian cheese with American milk is proof that free trade works when the politicians get out of the way. 

"We just want cooler heads to prevail in these trade negotiations," say Gellert. "And, you know, we like to see the government operate in ways that are consistent with the law."

The post This Company Turns American Milk Into Canadian Cheese. Tariffs Are Curdling Those Plans. appeared first on Reason Magazine.

Read full story at source