CRIME HUNTER: Did California mom-daughter murder tag team behead dad?

· Toronto Sun

Placer County in Northern California is a playground for devoted outdoors fanatics. Whitewater rafting, skiing and hiking are all on tap here.

Visit syntagm.co.za for more information.

But the area is also known for murder.

Joseph James DeAngelo Jr., aka the Golden State Killer, was a cop in Auburn, the county seat.

Now, another canvas of horror has been painted – in the exact same community where DeAngelo lived before being arrested in 2018: Citrus Heights. It’s not exactly a hotbed of violent crime, but in addition to the Golden State Killer, the area was home to another horror show.

In August 2001, Nikolay Soltys went on the run after fatally stabbing his wife, young son, aunt, uncle, two young cousins and his wife’s unborn child.

Soltys was nabbed following a tense 10-day manhunt. He was discovered hiding in the backyard of his mom’s Citrus Heights home.

Horror returned 21 years later.

On Sept. 28, 2022, Placer County deputies responded to the macabre discovery of a severed human head in a trash bag that had been discovered by a person walking their dog. At the time, detectives were unable to identify the victim due to the state of decomposition.

Who did head belong to?

They were also unable to link the victim to any outstanding missing persons or homicide cases that matched the circumstances.

An autopsy was conducted, and the victim’s skull was sent to California State University, Chico, where forensic experts developed a preliminary age and race profile. They also created an artist’s rendering of what the victim may have looked like in life.

Homicide detectives then used the information to search for a possible match among missing persons cases, but their efforts proved unsuccessful. The victim’s DNA was also entered into the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS), but no matches were found.

Desperate cops threw everything but the kitchen sink into their attempts to identify the person who belonged to the severed head. There was only one option left, a move that had solved hundreds of cold case investigations.

Began tracing John Doe’s family tree

According to cops, in January 2024, investigators sent the victim’s DNA to Othram Labs in Texas for forensic genetic genealogy testing. Othram developed a genealogical profile that helped zero in on possible distant relatives of the victim.

Genealogical detectives began tracing the dead man’s family tree using the info obtained by Othram. FBI agents also helped out by interviewing distant relatives and obtaining their DNA for comparison.

The tragic victim was identified last week as Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., who was 73 years old at the time of his death. Fitzmaurice – a retired environmental scientist – lived in Citrus Heights and had never been reported missing.

One neighbour, who withheld his name, thought something was askew.

“I wondered what happened to Paul a few years ago,” the neighbor told KLTV . “I hadn’t seen him around. I asked how he was doing, and nobody ever even said he passed or he died or he was sick or anything. They just stopped talking.”

“They” were the dead man’s now-widow, 75-year-old Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, and their daughter, 45-year-old Mary Fitzmaurice.

Fitzmaurice never reported missing

“The investigation continued once we had him identified, and we realized that Paul had never been reported missing,” Placer County Sheriff Wayne Woo said.

Still, mother and daughter continued receiving Paul Fitzmaurice’s Social Security benefits and his CalPERS (California Public Employees’ Retirement System) pension. Good work if you can get it.

In fact, his pensions totalled a whopping $12,000 CDN per month.

Woo added: “Fitzmaurice Jr. was reportedly estranged from his relatives, leading to Mary and Gwen allegedly telling them that he was suffering from some substance abuse issues and he was being a recluse and he would disappear for days at a time, but, you know, that he was very well still alive and would come back to the house, every week or so and stay for a couple of days.”

That was not the case – Paul Fitzmaurice was very dead and all indicators were pointing to a mother-daughter murder tag team.

RECOMMENDED VIDEO

Created facade to collect benefits

Detectives served a search warrant Tuesday at the family’s home, and Mary and Gwenn Fitzmaurice were arrested later that day. Investigators allege the former was responsible for killing her father before she and her mother conspired to dispose of his remains.

“We discovered that Gwenn and Mary had kept up the façade to family and friends that Paul was still alive, and in fact, they were still receiving Paul’s Social Security benefits and his CalPERS pension,” Woo alleged.

More charges are expected

Further investigation allegedly revealed Mary Fitzmaurice was responsible for her father’s murder at their family home in Citrus Heights with the mother-daughter team conspiring to dispose of his remains. Specifically, six garbage bags filled with what was left of the scientist.

Later Tuesday, Gwenn and Mary Fitzmaurice were taken into custody and booked into the South Placer Jail. Mary was booked on murder charges while Gwenn was booked on accessory charges.

Cops say they expect to lay more charges against the accused mother-daughter death squad.

Both women are being held on bail and charged with criminal conspiracy among other things.

[email protected]

@HunterTOSun

Read full story at source