Lessons in Vanderbilt Football: Alabama

· Yahoo Sports

NASHVILLE, TENNESSEE - NOVEMBER 14: Jared Curtis #2 of the Vanderbilt Commodores passes the ball against the Alabama Crimson Tide in the first half at FirstBank Stadium on November 14, 2026 in Nashville, Tennessee. (Photo by Carly Mackler/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Losing to Alabama 21-6 was definitely better than what our staff expected. Only Cole took us to cover the 15.5-point spread. No one is happy with a loss, but that was much more competitive than anyone expected. The frustration of “missed opportunities” was constant though.

The opening drive crossed midfield then sputtered and ended in a punt after a drop on 3rd down.  A drive that started on the Alabama 46 after a 4th down slip sack by Keelon Russell ended in a punt after a hold negated a 12-yard first down carry and a drop by Cole Spence. A Dontae Carter tip-and-pick could only be turned into a FG after a first down false start then 2 runs that lost yardage and a sack for -17 yards for the drive. Two false starts in Alabama territory halted a promising drive for a Brock Taylor 57-yard FG make. Three late-game drives ended on downs with two inside the Alabama 15 and the other at midfield. A bad snap also led to a Brock Taylor 50-yard miss.  To sound like an Alabama or Tennessee fan, Alabama did not beat Vanderbilt. Vanderbilt beat Vanderbilt.

Visit orlando-books.blog for more information.

Lessons We Know Well

Penalties. Freaking Penalties. There was a false start on 1st down to start the third drive by Caleb Azubuike. He fale started again on the next drive. There was also an offside that was declined after a 23-yard completion, but the free play may have led to the courage to make a deep, tight-window throw. Miles Capers did have an offside on 3rd down accepted, but the defense made the stop thanks to Russell falling on 4th down trying to avoid pressure. Veney started consecutive drives with a hold then a false start. Cayden Daniels was then called for an iffy pass interference (did get arm around but WR sold the actual interference) then a complete ghost of a defensive holding in the end zone on 3rd and 9 that was incomplete. Another defensive holding that should have been a push off on the WR for a stiff arm to the face was declined in favor of the TD catch from the push off. Mitchell Smith had the first of the two false starts that resulted in Taylor’s 57-yarder while Ja’Cory Thomas is credited with the other but shares responsibility with Jared Curtis for not checking everyone was set. There were 2 more false starts then a hold to negate a 11-yard carry for a first down to Alabama’s 11 on one of the turnover on downs within the Alabama 15. Yes, penalties were just about the most important stat in the game with the Commodores having 14 penalties for 92 yards. Take out half of those, and Vanderbilt might have won without changing anything else.

Brock Taylor had another great day with 2 makes from 54 and 57 yards. He did have a miss from 50 that was both short and right, but the snap was low and inside of the holder and never got set correctly. It disrupted Taylor’s approach timing and meant the kick was all leg from an almost standstill. Even if it was just a straight up miss, going 2 of 3 from 50+ is more than good enough from a college kicker.

Tyler Ebel was a weapon taking dangerous punt returner Ryan Coleman-Williams totally out of the game. His first kick was only 32 yards but was fair caught at the Alabama 14. Then he hit a low line drive that only traveled 38 yards in the air then bounced and rolled 22 more yards to the Alabama 4. A coffin corner beauty put a 43-yard boot out at the Alabama 19. Then he got the driver out for a 60-yard blast from the back of his own end zone that sent Coleman-Williams retreating so hard he feel down fielding the punt. A 48-yard punt landed at the Alabama 3 then kicked hard right out of bounds at the 2. Then he got the big stick out again for a 60-yard rocket that was returned 18 yards, so it still netted 42 yards. Special teams was doing everything they could to win this game.

The “clean” play was also generally there. Except for 1 decision to have Justin Dewers go for the high kickoff to the 5. Alabama took the bait for the return and took it all the way back to Vanderbilt’s 12. Yes, there were probably player errors in kick coverage, but it was an unforced coaching error to not just launch it into the end zone. The score was 14-6. There was no need to get tricky.

The offensive line had a rough day. Yes, Alabama’s front is nasty, but the OL penalties just made their own lives’ worse. Negating the effective runs did a lot to hurt the rushing averages. Sedrick Alexander had 6 official carries for 27 yards. Makhilyn Young had 6 for 9, Martel Hight got tackled for a loss on his lone carry, which appeared to be setup as a jet sweep pass that he never got to throw. Curtis had a big run marked off and also got sacked a few times, so his 9 carries for -18 is not helpful.  Florida is 50th in nation in yards per carry allowed at 3.83 YPC. The Commodores, on the road, need to stay clean. If they can even average 3+ yards, it will give them a chance.

The main man behind them had a day that was a bit of a slow build. Early in the game, it was clear the plan was to protect him from mistakes.  It took until Vanderbilt’s 10th drive of the game to get a deep completion. There were only 3 attempts before that. They never did go to the fan favorite Ja’Cory Thomas sideline deep shot. Statistically, he was 25 of 40 for 223 yards, and the rushing stats above. The 42.3 Total QBR reflects that Curtis was also errant on a few throws he should make. Some of the misses were pretty clearly nerves about the moment and mistakes as they were misses to stay well away from any risk. I really hope the coaches, and Curtis himself, have him in a more positive mindset for this one. Go play. The defense is stepping up to give you some room for error.

Junior Sherrill had another reliable, effective game. His 7 catches for 100 yards are sort of ho-hum for him. He did have a ball go between his hands on 4th and 3 that was one of the late-game turnover on downs.

The supporting cast had a couple drops. Spence and Brown both had important ones. Spence actually had 2, but neither were perfect throws either, so we can split it to be just one drop. Still, it was a day where a lot of players got involved. There were 9 players with a reception. Thomas only had 1 catch, and I am at a bit of a loss on that one. He was only targeted one other time that I remember.

Lessons We Are Learning

I wanted to bump this up a spot because it is 3 games in a row where the defense has more than done their part. Functionally, they gave up 14 points to Alabama because I am not pinning the TD where Alabama started 12 yards from paydirt on them. They also forced two turnovers during play and a turnover on downs. Dontae Carter tipped a pass while blitzing then caught it to set the offense up 17 yards from the end zone. Miles Capers strip-sacked Russell, and Talan Carter ran it back to the Alabama 42. They gave up 309 yards and held Alabama to 6.6 yards per pass and 2.6 yards per carry. If they show up like that in Gainesville today, the offense will, again, be in good position to pick up a win.

There was some more misdirection fun like we saw in Starkville. Hight had a jet sweep pass call. There were a number of jet sweeps or plays off jet sweep fakes. Really, the only critique of playcalling was that Curtis was not allowed to get to intermediate and deep throws, but the OL struggles along with a shoulder ding on the 2nd drive may have played into that.

The “identity” question comes back as “committing lots of penalties” apparently. They were generally aggressive. They just kept shooting themselves in the foot. The plans were clear. Players were committed. They just could not get out of their own way. Get focused on doing the little things right.

Lessons for Further Study

Can this team finish strong enough to get a consolation bowl? If the defense can stay this strong and the offense finds a way to stop shooting themselves in the foot, a win in Gainesville is very possible. Then we get to rivalry week.

Extra Credit (Your Questions)

I am lumping the two together because they were both focused on Curtis. I think Curtis is going through the normal growing pains for a highly talented freshman thrust into a tough spot. This is not the most talented team around him. It is good by Vanderbilt standards, but the OL struggles are not helping anyone out, especially as the offense keeps getting into 3rd and long. I cannot figure out Beck’s train of thought either on whether he does not trust Curtis or is trying to change too much of the formula and getting out of his own depth.

Read full story at source